A disk-shaped aircraft does not have to belong to science fiction. During the Second World War, Vought built and flew the V-173, an experimental machine with a broad, rounded wing and enormous propellers. Its surviving airframe and documented engineering history make it a useful subject for UFO research—but not because it explains every flying-saucer report. It shows how much more an identification requires than a suggestive silhouette.
A strange shape with an ordinary engineering purpose
The designer was Charles H. Zimmerman, an engineer at the National Advisory Committee for Aeronautics, NASA’s predecessor. NASA’s historical biography traces his low-speed aircraft research to 1933. He investigated wings with what the agency calls “flying saucer” shapes, combined with large propellers whose wakes passed over the wing. The objective was additional lift at low speeds and shorter takeoff and landing distances.
This was a practical aviation problem, particularly for aircraft operating from ships. A machine that could remain controllable at very low speed might need less deck space. Zimmerman tested models, left Langley for Chance Vought in 1937 and helped obtain Navy backing for a proof-of-concept aircraft. NASA records that the V-173 was tested in the Langley Full-Scale Tunnel and flown by pilots including Charles Lindbergh.
The Smithsonian’s collection record explains the aerodynamic reasoning: placing large propellers at the wing tips was intended to reduce the adverse effects of disturbed airflow there. Unusual geometry was a design choice with an engineering rationale, not evidence of unfamiliar physics.
What “almost hover” leaves out
The aircraft’s nickname, the “Flying Pancake,” captures its appearance better than its workings. The National Air and Space Museum’s restoration account identifies two wooden prop-rotors powered by two 80-horsepower Continental A-80 engines. The collection description records conventional control surfaces as well as the unusual wing arrangement.
Museum histories say the aircraft could “almost hover.” That phrase needs its conditions attached. An Air & Space Quarterly feature describes a zero-roll takeoff with a 30-mph headwind. Very little movement relative to the ground does not mean there is no airflow over a wing. Nor does a headwind-assisted takeoff demonstrate unrestricted helicopter-like hovering in still air.
For a UAP viewer, this is a useful distinction between ground motion, air motion and camera appearance. The published account documents remarkable low-speed behaviour for this particular propeller-driven design. It does not establish silent propulsion, instantaneous acceleration or gravity-defying flight. Those would be different claims requiring different measurements.
Do not merge the demonstrator and the fighter
Another source of confusion is the relationship between the V-173 and the larger XF5U-1. The Smithsonian collection record says the Navy ordered the latter after the experimental work showed promise. It was a more substantial development with much more powerful engines and a complex transmission arrangement. The same record says it was completed but never flown.
That matters when photographs, drawings and performance claims circulate together. A flight demonstrated by the V-173 is not automatically a demonstrated capability of the XF5U-1. Equally, a proposed fighter’s intended performance should not be attached to the smaller experimental aircraft as an achieved result.
The histories emphasize somewhat different aspects of the programme’s end. NASA describes development delays and declining Navy interest after the war; the Smithsonian emphasizes the turn toward turbojet propulsion. These accounts provide conventional development context. Neither supplies evidence that the cancellation concealed successful exotic technology.
A physical artifact—and a small discrepancy
The evidence extends beyond retrospective storytelling. The Smithsonian catalogues the surviving V-173 as inventory number A19610120000 and records its transfer from the Navy. Its March 2012 restoration article describes an eight-year effort by retired Vought employees, including preservation of cockpit wear and replacement of three missing instruments. These are concrete details about an identified object and its conservation.
Even these institutional pages should not be treated as perfectly interchangeable. The collection record describes a 139-hour test programme, while the restoration article and Quarterly feature give 131 hours of flying time. Those may reflect different accounting or an editorial discrepancy; the pages reviewed do not resolve it. There is no need to invent a reconciliation.
The central point survives that uncertainty: this was a real, flown experimental aircraft. Precise test totals would call for the underlying logs. A transparent research note can preserve a firm conclusion while marking a narrower detail as unsettled.
What this can—and cannot—do for UFO identification
The V-173 establishes that a rounded, unfamiliar-looking aircraft existed within documented human aviation. It does not establish that a particular witness saw it. Matching an actual sighting would require the date, location, viewing direction, aircraft movements and the reported appearance or sound. A resemblance alone cannot supply those missing links.
The reasoning works both ways. An observer’s difficulty recognizing a machine does not make its origin extraterrestrial. But finding a photograph of an unusual prototype does not entitle an investigator to close an unrelated case. “A possible class of explanation” and “the identified object in this event” are different evidentiary stages.
Managing expectations
When an archival aircraft image appears in a UFO discussion, start with its catalogue entry. Check the model designation, whether the pictured vehicle actually flew, and whether the accompanying performance numbers are measured results or design ambitions. Keep wind conditions attached to claims about hovering or vertical takeoff.
The Flying Pancake deserves attention as inventive engineering, not as a shortcut to either belief or dismissal. Its strongest lesson is methodological: a named designer, test history, documented hardware and surviving artifact can turn an unfamiliar shape into a specific aircraft. An unexplained sighting needs its own comparable chain of evidence.
Sources and scope
- Official collection record: National Air and Space Museum — Vought V-173 “Flying Pancake”. Airframe identity, design rationale and XF5U-1 distinction.
- Institutional restoration account: National Air and Space Museum — Vought retirees finish restoration (March 20, 2012). Engines, conservation and reported flying time.
- Official engineering history: NASA — Charles H. Zimmerman (May 25, 2017). NACA research, model tests, Vought and development context.
- Museum historical feature: Air & Space Quarterly — Smithsonian In Your Backyard: World War II Aircraft. V-173 section, headwind condition and restoration history.
Source check: October 25, 2026. Four source pages from NASA and the Smithsonian, not four independent investigations. These are a collection record and institutional histories, not a fresh examination of original flight logs or a resolution of any individual UFO sighting.
UAP / UFO Research: People, Films & Sightings
Source-grounded research, clear evidence labels and conclusions proportionate to the record.
Back to UAP Topic Back to Blog